Your nonprofit website might be costing you donors, volunteers, and trust — without you knowing it.
Most nonprofit sites I look at are one of two things: a donation portal barely dressed up as a website, or a sprawling archive of every program and initiative the organization has ever run. Neither of those works for the person who finds you for the first time. Here's what to do about it.
1. Simplify Your Navigation
If someone lands on your site and has to think too hard to figure out where to go, they'll leave. And they won't come back.
A lot of nonprofit websites suffer from navigation that was built for staff, not for visitors. You hit a dropdown and get: Programs, Initiatives, Impact Reports, Our Team, Volunteer, Donate, Events, News, Partners, Advocacy. That's not navigation — that's a filing cabinet.
Your main nav should have five or six items, max. Something like: About, Our Work, Get Involved, Donate, Contact. Everything else lives deeper in the site where motivated visitors can find it.
Every link you add to your navigation is asking your visitor to make a decision. Most of the time, they'll make the decision to leave instead.
2. Treat Your Homepage Like a Marketing Page
Your homepage is where someone decides whether your cause is worth their time, their money, or their energy. Most nonprofit homepages waste that moment on history and jargon.
The first thing a visitor should see is not your founding year or your mission statement. It's a clear, specific line that makes them feel the problem you're solving. Not "We serve the community." Not "Empowering lives since 1998." Something that puts a face on the issue and makes the person reading it feel something.
Donald Miller's StoryBrand framework is a good map here. The short version: your donor or volunteer is the hero of the story. Your organization is the guide that helps them do something meaningful. Lead with what's at stake for the people you serve — and make the visitor feel like they're the one who can change it.
Not sure where your nonprofit's messaging breaks down? Take the free Mission & Marketing Scorecard — 5 minutes to find out exactly where to focus first.
3. Pick One Clear Call to Action
How many times does your homepage ask a visitor to do something? Donate. Volunteer. Subscribe to the newsletter. Sign the petition. Follow us on Instagram. Watch the video.
Every ask you add dilutes every other ask. When people have five options, they pick zero.
Choose a primary action and a secondary one. For most nonprofits, the primary is Donate or Get Involved, depending on what you need most right now. The secondary might be Volunteer or Learn More About Our Work.
Make those two things visually obvious. Put the primary call to action in your header so it follows the visitor as they scroll. Put it again after your impact numbers. After your story section. Be clear and be direct — if you don't tell people what to do next, they won't do anything.
4. Design Actually Matters
This one gets pushed to the bottom of the priority list at most nonprofits because budgets are tight and staff time is short. But a poorly designed website signals something to a first-time visitor, and it's not "they're focused on the mission." It's "something is off here."
You don't need to spend thousands on a custom design. But you do need clean fonts, real photos, consistent colors, and enough whitespace that the page doesn't feel overwhelming. A site that looks like it hasn't been touched since 2015 is a trust killer — especially for larger donors who will absolutely judge your credibility by how the site looks.
Your website design is part of your credibility. Make sure it reflects your organization's actual quality.
5. Give Your Communications Team a Voice
Here's the structural problem a lot of nonprofits have: the website is owned by IT or an admin, and it slowly becomes an internal document system instead of a tool for reaching new people.
Every page starts to serve existing stakeholders — board members, program staff, longtime donors — instead of the stranger who just heard about you and wants to know if you're worth trusting.
Your communications or marketing team, even if that's one person or a volunteer, needs real authority over what's on the homepage, how the site sounds, and what story it tells. They're thinking about the person on the outside looking in. That perspective is too important to be overruled by whoever controls the CMS login.
Frequently Asked Questions
What should a nonprofit website homepage include?
A clear, emotionally compelling headline that names the problem you're solving, a primary call to action (Donate or Get Involved), a brief section showing impact with real numbers, and a story or testimonial that puts a face on the cause. Everything else — program details, staff bios, annual reports — lives on interior pages.
How do I get more donations through my nonprofit website?
Start by reducing friction: one clear Donate button in the header, a simple donation form, and a compelling reason to give above the fold. Most nonprofit sites have the donate button buried three clicks deep. Move it up. Make the impact of each donation level specific — "Your $50 feeds a family for a week" converts far better than a generic ask.
How often should a nonprofit update its website?
Homepage messaging and impact stats should be reviewed at least twice a year. Program pages whenever your offerings change. The biggest mistake is leaving outdated numbers or old events visible — it signals to donors that nobody's managing the organization carefully.
What is the best call to action for a nonprofit website?
It depends on your current priority — if you need money, make Donate the primary CTA. If you need capacity, make Volunteer or Get Involved primary. What matters most is picking one and making it obvious. A homepage that asks visitors to do six different things will convert at a fraction of one with a single clear ask.
Is Your Nonprofit's Marketing Working?
Take the free Mission & Marketing Scorecard — 5 minutes to find out exactly where your communication strategy is strong and where it's costing you donors.
Take the Free Scorecard →Need Help Fixing Your Nonprofit Website?
I work with nonprofits to turn their websites from internal documents into tools that actually bring in donors and volunteers. Let's talk about what that looks like for yours.
Work With JT →