Your church website is probably hurting your church. That's a hard thing to say, but most church websites I look at are doing one of two things: confusing new visitors so badly they leave, or serving the staff so well that guests don't get a second thought.
Here's the good news — the fix isn't complicated. It's five things. And if you do them, your website will actually work for the people you're trying to reach.
1. Simplify Your Navigation
Go to your church website right now and count your menu items. If you can hit a dropdown and see fifteen links — every ministry, every program, every event — you have a problem.
A first-time visitor looking for your service times shouldn't have to figure out whether that's under "Ministries," "What's New," or "Community." And honestly, neither should your members. When people can't find what they need, they don't ask for help. They leave.
Your main navigation should have five links. Maybe six if you're pushing it. New Here, Sermons, Events, Give, Contact. That's the whole job. Every ministry page, every staff bio, every deep link — those live deeper in the site, reachable once someone already knows they want to be there.
If you're afraid of hiding something important, ask yourself: is it important to a guest, or is it important to your staff? Those are two very different websites.
2. Treat Your Homepage Like a Marketing Page
Your homepage is not a church bulletin. Stop treating it like one.
The most important thing on your homepage is the first line — and most church homepages waste it on a Bible verse or a motto that means nothing to someone who's never been inside your doors. That line needs to do one specific job: make the person reading it feel seen.
Donald Miller's StoryBrand framework is built for exactly this. The idea is simple: your visitor is the hero, not your church. They have a problem, you have a solution. Lead with their problem.
What does your community actually struggle with? If you're in an inner city where people are fighting addiction or violence, your first line should acknowledge that world. If you're in a rural area where isolation is real and families are the center of life, your first line should sound like that. Generic doesn't work. "A place for everyone" doesn't work. "Find your people" doesn't work. Speak to the specific person in your specific place.
Not sure where your church's marketing breaks down? Take the free Mission & Marketing Scorecard — 5 minutes to find out exactly where to focus first.
3. Pick One Clear Call to Action
Count the calls to action on your homepage. If there are more than two, you have too many.
"Plan Your Visit." "Get Connected." "Reach Out to a Pastor." "See Locations." Every option you add is friction. When people have too many choices, they make no choice at all.
Pick a primary action and a secondary action. That's it. For most churches, the primary call to action should be Plan Your Visit. That's what you actually want — a real person in a real seat. Make that button impossible to miss. Put it in your header, on your hero section, after your about section.
Your secondary action depends on your church. Maybe it's Watch Live for churches with a strong online presence. Maybe it's Text Us if you've got a pastoral care line. Pick one and let it breathe. The goal isn't to list everything your church offers — it's to tell the visitor what to do next.
4. Design Actually Matters
I know pastors and church admins who resist this one. "It's about the message, not the look." Yes — and a poorly designed website undermines your message before anyone reads a word of it.
We have no excuse anymore. Canva, Squarespace, Webflow — you can build a clean, well-branded website without hiring a design agency. There's no reason for blurry photos, fonts that clash, or color schemes that look like they were assembled in 2009.
A few things to get right: consistent colors (pick two or three and stick with them), readable text (enough contrast between your background and your type), and real photos of your actual church — not stock images of strangers holding Bibles.
Your website's design is the first impression. It signals whether your church is alive and intentional, or on autopilot. A guest who lands on a dated, cluttered site doesn't think "they're focused on what matters." They think "nobody's home."
5. Put the Right People in Charge of It
This is the one most churches get wrong at the root.
Too often, the church website is owned by IT or the admin team. And those folks are great — but they're optimizing for a different thing. They want it accurate and functional. What you need is a website that's compelling to someone who doesn't know your church at all.
Your creative team — whether that's staff or volunteers who understand design and storytelling — needs a seat at the table. Not just to pick the font, but to make real decisions about what goes on the page, what the photos look like, and what the voice of the site sounds like. Because your website is a marketing tool, even if that word makes you uncomfortable. The goal is for a stranger to land on it and think, I want to be there.
Admins keep it running. Creatives make it matter. You need both.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I fix my church website to attract more visitors?
Start with your navigation and your homepage headline. Simplify the menu to five or six items and rewrite your first line to speak directly to the problem your community faces — not your mission statement. Those two changes alone will improve how visitors experience your site before you touch anything else.
What should a church website homepage include?
A clear headline that speaks to your ICP, a primary call to action (Plan Your Visit), service times that are easy to find, a brief section about what to expect, and a secondary call to action. Everything else — ministries, staff bios, events — lives deeper in the site.
What is the best call to action for a church website?
"Plan Your Visit" is the strongest primary CTA for most churches because it sets a clear expectation and invites physical presence. Pair it with a secondary option like "Watch Live" if you have an online audience worth serving. Avoid vague CTAs like "Get Connected" or "Learn More" — they don't tell anyone what to actually do.
How often should a church update its website?
Homepage messaging should be reviewed at least annually. Event pages and sermon content need to stay current — outdated events on a homepage signal to visitors that nobody is paying attention. Assign ownership to someone on your creative or communications team who checks it monthly.
Is Your Church's Marketing Working?
Take the free Mission & Marketing Scorecard — 5 minutes to find out exactly where your ministry communication is strong and where it's costing you.
Take the Free Scorecard →Need Help Fixing Your Church Website?
I work with churches and nonprofits to get their websites doing what they're supposed to — bringing in real people. Let's talk about what that looks like for yours.
Work With JT →